Judge Urges more Deliberations in Android Case

May 04, 2012 07:02 PM EDT

Share This Story

  • Print
  • Email

(Reuters) - A judge urged jurors to resume deliberating Oracle Corp's copyright claims against Google over the Android mobile platform, after they indicated there was unanimous agreement on all but one of the questions they must decide.

Follow us

"It's worth you going home over weekend," District Judge William Alsup told the jurors, adding that deliberations in the federal court in San Francisco should continue next week.

Oracle sued Google in August 2010, saying Android infringes on its intellectual property rights to the Java programming language. Google says it does not violate Oracle's patents and that Oracle cannot copyright certain parts of Java, an "open-source," or publicly available, software language.

Alsup had been prepared to allow the jury to deliver a partial verdict on Friday. But he changed his mind after one juror said others on the panel thought further deliberations might be useful.

"We should take advantage of that hope," Alsup said.

The trial has been divided into three phases: copyright liability, patent claims, and damages. It began in April and was expected to last at least eight weeks.

If the jury cannot agree on one question, Alsup has indicated he would allow them to deliver a partial verdict and move on to hear evidence in the patent phase of the case. Another jury may then have to resolve the unanswered copyright question on a retrial.

The case in U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, is Oracle America, Inc v. Google Inc, 10-3561.

Get the Most Popular Mobile&Apps Stories in a Weekly Newsletter

Copyright 2013 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.

Join Our Conversation

Smartphones
Galaxy S4 Google EditionSamsung Galaxy S4 Google Edition: $649 Price Tag Explained
Nokia EOS Details Allegedly Leaked: Once Again Nokia Focuses On The Camera
Samsung Galaxy Note 3 May Sport Same Familiar Plastic Design, Not Metal
Intellicam App Brings First Hands-Free Camera Feature To Windows Phone 8
Tablet / Laptop / PC
Nexus 7Nexus 7 Refresh Teased In Google+ Hangouts Video, Sports Glowing Notification Light
AMD Unleashes Radeon 8900M Mobile GPU: Get It In MSI GX70 Gaming Laptop
Dell XPS 10 Drops Price To $300, Marking A New Low For Windows RT
HP Slatebook x2 Convertible Laptop Rocks Nvidia Tegra 4, Android 4.2 Jelly Bean
Gadgets
Google GlassGoogle Glass Raises Lawmakers' Concerns: Congress Demands Answers About Privacy
Seven New Apps Coming To Google Glass: Facebook, Twitter, And Evernote Included
Android 4.2.2 Jelly Bean, Chrome Update For Google TV: End Of Flash?
AMD Unleashes Radeon 8900M Mobile GPU: Get It In MSI GX70 Gaming Laptop
OS / Software
Samsung Galaxy S4 Gets TCO CertificationSamsung Galaxy S4 Gets TCO Certification
Android 4.3 Jelly Bean Coming On June 10: Absent From Google I/O 2013 Intentionally
Android 4.2.2 Jelly Bean, Chrome Update For Google TV: End Of Flash?
Google Wallet Update: Send Money To Friends With Gmail, Make One-Click Purchases On The Go
Internet / Social Media
The Yahoo logYahoo Is Eyeing Tumblr
Google I/O 2013: Chrome Web Browser Now Has 750 Million Active Users
Google I/O 2013: Google Maps Gets New UI And Google+ Hangouts Shows Massive Improvements
Gtalk Chat Integration Coming To Outlook.com
What's App
Intellicam Windows Phone 8Intellicam App Brings First Hands-Free Camera Feature To Windows Phone 8
Seven New Apps Coming To Google Glass: Facebook, Twitter, And Evernote Included
Itsdagram Available Now For Windows Phone: Best Instagram Client Around
Google I/O 2013: Chrome Web Browser Now Has 750 Million Active Users

DON'T MISS

Galaxy S4 White Frost
Verizon Samsung Galaxy S4 To Come On May 23
According to an update on Verizon's news page, the Galaxy S4 will now be available in Verizon
Galaxy S4 Google Edition
Samsung Galaxy S4 Google Edition Launched: Rumors Say It's Nexus 5
The new edition of the Galaxy S4 is being seen as an alternative to the Nexus smartphones as the
RIM BlackBerry 10
BlackBerry Live: 120,000 Apps in BlackBerry World, Gaining on Windows Phone
The numbers are in, and it appears BlackBerry World might walk over Windows Phone sooner or later.
Windows Blue
Windows 'Blue' Will Come As Free Update For Windows 8, Windows RT Users
Despite previous rumors, Windows 8.1 dubbed Windows 'Blue' will be available as a free update to
LG Google TV
Android 4.2.2 Jelly Bean, Chrome Update For Google TV: End Of Flash?
The Google TV has now be 'refactored' so the OEMs of the device can update their settop boxes to
Samsung Galaxy S4 'Blue Arctic'
Samsung Galaxy S4 Blue Arctic Gets Official On Docomo Network
Samsung Galaxy S4 Blue Arctic is real but it is not yet clear whether the handset is exclusively

Galaxy S4 White Frost
Samsung To Look Into 16GB Galaxy S4 Storage Woes, 'Software Optimization' Might Free More Space
Samsung has finally responded to storage woes concerning the 16GB Samsung Galaxy S4 and said it may
Samsung Galaxy S4 Mini 'Leaked' Image
Samsung Galaxy S4 Mini Spotted In Leaked Images Once Again
In the latest series of leaked pictures, the Galaxy S4 mini is shown from every possible angle and
Google Maps
Google I/O 2013: Google Maps Gets New UI And Google+ Hangouts Shows Massive Improvements
Fans of Google products will love the new look of Google Maps and Google+ Hangouts.
MSI GX70
AMD Unleashes Radeon 8900M Mobile GPU: Get It In MSI GX70 Gaming Laptop
Do you enjoy gaming on a laptop? The AMD Radeon 8900M might excite you along with the MSI GX70.
Copyright © 2013 Mobile & Apps All rights reserved. mobilenapps
Real Time Analytics