Apple vs. Samsung: Judge Slashes $450M Off Damages Award, Sets New Trial

By Alexandra Burlacu | Mar 03, 2013 12:19 PM EST

Share This Story

  • Print
  • Email

Apple faces a major setback in its mobile patents battle against Samsung Electronics, as a federal judge slashed the damages award and set a new trial.

Last year, Apple won a $1.05 billion jury award against Samsung in what was the biggest and highest-profile case in the global dispute between the two tech giants. In today's highly competitive market, Apple and Samsung are waging a war over the use and alleged abuse of mobile patents.

Follow us

On Friday, March 1, a federal judge slashed the $1.05 billion damages award by more than 40 percent and set a new trial to determine the actual damages.

"We are pleased that the court decided to strike $450,514,650 from the jury's award," Samsung boasted in a statement, as cited by Reuters. "Samsung intends to seek further review as to the remaining award."

The ruling on Friday comes from Judge Lucy Koh of the U.S. District Court Northern District of California in San Jose. The new ruling means the legal dispute between the two tech giants is far from over. With a new damages trial set, Apple and Samsung may once again go head to head in a California court to argue how much of the $450.05 million slashed from the damages should stand. Te damages are associated with 14 Samsung products which Apple claims are infringing.

Judge Koh said the jury erroneously calculated part of the damages, which means that a new trial is needed to determine the actual and final damages amount. Koh rejected Apple's motion to increase the jury's damages award and ordered a new trial on damages for all 14 devices in question, including the Samsung Galaxy S3. The jury's nearly $599 million award to Apple for 14 other separate products still stands.

"The court has identified an impermissible legal theory on which the jury based its award and cannot reasonably calculate the amount of excess while effectuating the intent of the jury," the judge explains in her ruling, according to Reuters.

Samsung and Apple are the world's two biggest smartphone makers, and each scored victories in their patent disputes spanning over four continents. The two tech giants are fighting for dominance of an increasingly growing mobile-device market, and Apple accused Samsung of "slavishly copying" its devices. Despite all the legal fuss, however, Apple remains one of Samsung's biggest customers.

Get the Most Popular Mobile&Apps Stories in a Weekly Newsletter

© 2013 Mobile & Apps All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join Our Conversation

Smartphones
Nokia Lumia 928Verizon Exclusive Nokia Lumia 928 Now $49.99 At Online Retailers
Android 4.2.2 Jelly Bean Update For Samsung Galaxy S3 Leaked
Samsung Galaxy S4 App Contest Boasts $800,000 Total Prizes For Talented Devs
Photo Taken With Samsung Galaxy Note 3 'Leaked' Online
Tablet / Laptop / PC
Asus 1015E NotebookAsus 1015E Ubuntu Notebook To Launch Soon With $215 Price Tag
New MacBook Air To Debut In June With Intel's New Haswell Processor?
Nexus 7 Refresh Teased In Google+ Hangouts Video, Sports Glowing Notification Light
AMD Unleashes Radeon 8900M Mobile GPU: Get It In MSI GX70 Gaming Laptop
Gadgets
Ouya Android-Powered $99 Game ConsoleOuya Will Be At E3 2013, But Not Where You Think
Next Microsoft Xbox To Sport Dashboard UI Update And Tile Changes
Google Media Streamer Hits FCC To Replace Nexus Q
Google Glass Raises Lawmakers' Concerns: Congress Demands Answers About Privacy
OS / Software
Galaxy S3 Mini Jelly Bean UpdateAndroid 4.2.2 Jelly Bean Update For Samsung Galaxy S3 Leaked
Samsung Galaxy S4 Mega Confirmed By Samsung In WatchOn Change Log?
Android 4.2.2 Jelly Bean Coming Soon For HTC One; Google Edition of HTC One On The Way
Android 4.1.2 Jelly Bean Official Firmware Update For Samsung Galaxy S3 I9300 Via XXEMD2 [How To Install]
Internet / Social Media
YouTube AppYouTube Shoppable Videos - Will Google Hit A New Jackpot?
Apple iRadio Reportedly Delayed Over Song Skipping Issue
Yahoo Is Eyeing Tumblr
Google I/O 2013: Chrome Web Browser Now Has 750 Million Active Users
What's App
Galaxy S4 White FrostSamsung Galaxy S4 App Contest Boasts $800,000 Total Prizes For Talented Devs
Intellicam App Brings First Hands-Free Camera Feature To Windows Phone 8
Seven New Apps Coming To Google Glass: Facebook, Twitter, And Evernote Included
Itsdagram Available Now For Windows Phone: Best Instagram Client Around

DON'T MISS

Galaxy S3 Sapphire Black
Android 4.1.2 Jelly Bean Official Firmware Update For Samsung Galaxy S3 I9300 Via XXEMD2 [How To Install]
The update comes with some features like Group CastApp and Page Buddy.
MacBook Air
New MacBook Air To Debut In June With Intel's New Haswell Processor?
Apple is expected to update its hardware lineup as soon as June with a new MacBook Air likely
HTC One
Android 4.2.2 Jelly Bean Coming Soon For HTC One; Google Edition of HTC One On The Way
According to Android Authority, "@LlabTooFeR says he knows about the HTC One without Sense 'for a
Galaxy S4 Launch in Korea
Galaxy S4 Best Selling Samsung Smartphone Of All Time?
Galaxy is the new iPhone, as the Samsung Galaxy S4 approaches 10 million devices shipped in less
Google Nexus 4 White Version
White Nexus 4 To Launch On June 10 Rocking Latest Android 4.3
The white Nexus 4 that created a lot of buzz among rumor mills recently, finally has a launch date:
Jabra HALO2 Bluetooth Stereo Headset
Amazon Deals Of The Day: Sony Xperia Z, Jabra HALO2 Bluetooth Stereo Headset And More
Here are some deals for those on a right budget, or for those who can't pass up on a good deal.

Nokia Lumia 925
Windows Phone Took Third Spot From BlackBerry In Latest Worldwide Market Share Report
The Windows Phone platform is definitely growing, but can it continue with this momentum?
HTC One
Sprint Releases Software Update For HTC One: Key Sensitivity Issues To Be Fixed
According to a post on Sprint's community page, the software build number 1.29. 651.10 has been
Pentagon
Apple iOS 6 Devices Cleared For Military Use In U.S.
The Pentagon has approved Apple devices running iOS 6 for use on its networks, which means Apple
RIM BlackBerry 10
BlackBerry Live: 120,000 Apps in BlackBerry World, Gaining on Windows Phone
The numbers are in, and it appears BlackBerry World might walk over Windows Phone sooner or later.
Copyright © 2013 Mobile & Apps All rights reserved. mobilenapps
Real Time Analytics