Apple Can Proceed With Siri Patent Case Against Samsung, Says Judge Koh

By Alexandra Burlacu | Mar 09, 2013 01:52 PM EST

Share This Story

  • Print
  • Email

A U.S. federal judge gave Apple the green light to proceed with its lawsuit against Samsung over its Siri digital assistant patents.

Judge Lucy Koh, a name already very familiar to those who follow the epic battle between Apple and Samsung, just ruled that she will not suspend Apple's lawsuit against its South Korean rival. This lawsuit concerns patterns that Apple uses for Siri and is different from the case that went to trial back in 2012.

Follow us

Last year, Apple won a $1.5 billion verdict against Samsung in a San Jose, Calif., trial, but Judge Koh denied Apple's request for a permanent injunction against sales of infringing Samsung devices. Apple also filed a separate lawsuit accusing Samsung of violating a set of patents, including one related to Siri voice search technology.

Apple appealed the judge's decision of the product ban in the first case, and Koh said last month that the second case, i.e. the Siri case, might be dismissed as the eventual ruling on the first case could ultimately resolve both cases.

"I just don't know if we really need two cases on this," Judge Koh said at the time, according to a Reuters account of the proceedings cited by CNET. Apple, of course, objected.

Now, the U.S. federal judge presiding over the landmark patent case between the tech giants in Northern California said that a second Apple patent suit against Samsung over Siri technology can go forward. For the case to proceed, however, both companies must "significantly" simplify the scope of the case by reducing the number of expert witnesses and expert witnesses, reports Reuters.

The Siri case against Samsung is set to go on trial this month. Meanwhile, Apple's appeal on Koh's rejection of a product ban in the first case will likely not reach a verdict until at least September 2013.


Earlier this month, Koh cited jury error in calculating the damages in the first case and slashed $450 million off the $1.05 billion damages award, ordering a new trial on the damages to recalculate everything. In conclusion, the war between Apple and Samsung seems far from over. 

 

 

Get the Most Popular Mobile&Apps Stories in a Weekly Newsletter

© 2013 Mobile & Apps All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join Our Conversation

Smartphones
LG logoLG to launch always-on, voice-controlled smartphone next year
BlackBerry Q10 arriving on AT&T on June 21
HTC unleashes Butterfly S: Price, specs, availability
Huawei wants to acquire Nokia, calls Windows Phone "weak"
Tablet / Laptop / PC
Microsoft Surface RTMicrosoft Surface RT 2 to rock Qualcomm 800 chip, Windows 8.1
AT&T Galaxy Note 8.0 LTE costs $399.99 on contract, $199.99 with smartphone bundles
Chromebooks land on Walmart, more retailers to get it soon
Apple's next iPad mini 7.9 inch Retina display will be Samsung-made
Gadgets
Nintendo 3DSNintendo 3DS outsold Microsoft Xbox 360 in the U.S.
AMD moves from Intel's x86 platform to ARM for servers
OUYA team and E3 organizers battle over parking lot space
Sony PlayStation 4 to be available at $399 at the end of this year
OS / Software
Sony PS3PS3 latest software update 4.45 bricking the consoles
Android 4.2.2 Jelly Bean update for Sony Xperia Z spotted in video
Windows Phone 8 GDR2 update reportedly coming in July
iOS 7 Beta comes with a bug that opens the lock screen to access photos [Video]
Internet / Social Media
Microsoft SoclMicrosoft Socl adds meme generator and GIF creator
What to expect from Facebook's June 20 event
WWDC 2013: OS X 10.9 Mavericks Safari is going to help you extend battery life
Samsung Galaxy S3 browser bug spikes data usage, slows loading times
What's App
Windows Phone 8 Microsoft paying app developers up to $100,000 to bring content to Windows Phone 8
Windows 8.1 brings newly updated Xbox Music app
Instagram may add video on June 20 to challenge Twitter's Vine
Microsoft Office now available for iPhones, but there's a catch

DON'T MISS

Android 5.0 Key Lime Pie
Android 5.0 Key Lime Pie, Motorola X Phone reportedly launching in October
The highly-anticipated Android 5.0 Key Lime Pie will reportedly make its debut in late October
Nexus 7
Next generation Google Nexus 7 could launch in July for $229
New Google Nexus 7 for $229 in July of 2013? This could be another hit Android product for Google.
Samsung Galaxy S4 Active
Samsung Galaxy S4 Active to be AT&T exclusive at $199.99
Samsung Galaxy S4 Active is going to be launched on June 21 and if you are interested in this water-
Samsung Galaxy S4
T-Mobile drops Galaxy S4 price by $50 for one month
There is some good news for people who are on T-Mobile network and want to buy the new Samsung
iPad mini
Apple's next iPad mini 7.9 inch Retina display will be Samsung-made
Apple's new iPad mini will sport 7.9 inch Retina display with 2048 x 1539 pixel resolution. The
Low cost iPhone
Low cost iPhone reportedly shipping in large numbers
Is Apple scrambling to launch a low-cost iPhone in 2013?
Microsoft Office 365 Home Premium
Microsoft Office now available for iPhones, but there's a catch
Microsoft finally released its Office Mobile for iPhone as a free app, but there's a catch: it's
Nokia EOS Leaked
Nokia EOS 41-megapixel camera smartphone may debut on July 11
Nokia has a big event scheduled for July 11 in New York and the 'Zoom. Reinvented' teaser on the
HTC Tiara
Sprint HTC Tiara Windows Phone 8 smartphone leaks in PR image
The Sprint-bound HTC Tiara made its way to the Internet in an official PR image, complete with
Galaxy S2 Jelly Bean Update
Android 4.1.2 Jelly Bean finally available for AT&T Samsung Galaxy S2 (SGH-I777)
Android 4.1.2 Jelly Bean update finally comes via Samsung Kies to put Samsung Galaxy S2 users on
Copyright © 2013 Mobile & Apps All rights reserved. mobilenapps
Real Time Analytics