Apple May Lose iPhone Brand Name In Mexico Over Existing 'Ifone' Brand

By Alexandra Burlacu | Mar 17, 2013 12:36 PM EDT

Share This Story

  • Print
  • Email

Apple is fighting to secure the legal rights to the iPhone name outside of the U.S., but suffered another major setback in a ruling this week.

For those unfamiliar with the issue, a Mexican technology services company is looking to reap some compensation from Apple and local mobile operators for the use of its brand name - Ifone. Mexico's Supreme Court already upheld a ruling that the local company owns and makes proper use of its brand in the country. 

Follow us

Apple's troubles in the country started in 2009, when the Cupertino giant tried to register its phone name in Mexico and learned from the Mexican Industrial Property Institute that the name was already taken.

The iPhone maker filed suit to have the Ifone brand revoked on grounds that it had expired for the Mexican company, but a federal court disagreed. Ifone SA was registered in 2003 and the court ruled that the Mexican firm was making proper use of it. This week, the Supreme Court dealt another blow to Apple, rejecting Apple's appeal against the decision.

In other words, the Mexico Supreme Court upheld the lower court's decision to continue granting the ownership of the iPhone name to Ifone SA, the Wall Street Journal reports.

Consequently, Ifone SA has its "Ifone" brand all to itself, though it doesn't have any smartphone products. In its own legal offensive filed with the Industrial Property Institute, the Mexican company is going after Apple and three local mobile carriers for monetary damages.

On the other hand, this is hardly the first time that Apple faces troubles with its product names outside the U.S., but all previous scuffles ended in settlements. Last year, the Cupertino giant fought Chinese company Proview for the rights to the iPad trademark in the country. Apple paid $60 million last July to settle that dispute.

More recently, Apple also faced some challenges in Brazil with local telecommunications firm IGB Electronica over the rights to the iPhone name. That matter is also close to a settlement.

A more notorious case was in the U.S., where Apple fought Cisco Systems in early 2007 for the iPhone name, just months after releasing the product. Cisco sued Apple for trademark infringement immediately after the iPhone unveiling in January 2007, but the companies settled one month later. How much will Apple pay now to settle the "Ifone" dispute in Mexico?

Get the Most Popular Mobile&Apps Stories in a Weekly Newsletter

© 2013 Mobile & Apps All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join Our Conversation

Smartphones
Quad-core Nokia Windows PhoneNokia Lumia Windows Phone 8 quad-core smartphone shows up in benchmarks
Leaked images highlight Nokia EOS aluminum body
HTC One will get Android 4.2.2 Jelly Bean update despite recent rumors
Oppo Find 7 may boast Snapdragon 800 processor, whopping 4000mAh battery
Tablet / Laptop / PC
Galaxy Note 8.0AT&T Galaxy Note 8.0 LTE costs $399.99 on contract, $199.99 with smartphone bundles
Chromebooks land on Walmart, more retailers to get it soon
Apple's next iPad mini 7.9 inch Retina display will be Samsung-made
Next generation Google Nexus 7 could launch in July for $229
Gadgets
AMD Seattle ServerAMD moves from Intel's x86 platform to ARM for servers
OUYA team and E3 organizers battle over parking lot space
Sony PlayStation 4 to be available at $399 at the end of this year
Mad Catz to unveil M.O.J.O. Android game console at E3 to challenge Ouya
OS / Software
Windows Phone 8Windows Phone 8 GDR2 update reportedly coming in July
iOS 7 Beta comes with a bug that opens the lock screen to access photos [Video]
Microsoft recovers missing Lumia 920 with prototype Windows Phone Blue
Android 5.0 Key Lime Pie, Motorola X Phone reportedly launching in October
Internet / Social Media
Facebook June 20 InviteWhat to expect from Facebook's June 20 event
WWDC 2013: OS X 10.9 Mavericks Safari is going to help you extend battery life
Samsung Galaxy S3 browser bug spikes data usage, slows loading times
Cisco appeals to European Commission to overturn Microsoft's 2011 acquisiton of Skype
What's App
Windows Phone 8 Microsoft paying app developers up to $100,000 to bring content to Windows Phone 8
Windows 8.1 brings newly updated Xbox Music app
Instagram may add video on June 20 to challenge Twitter's Vine
Microsoft Office now available for iPhones, but there's a catch

DON'T MISS

Android 5.0 Key Lime Pie
Android 5.0 Key Lime Pie, Motorola X Phone reportedly launching in October
The highly-anticipated Android 5.0 Key Lime Pie will reportedly make its debut in late October
Nexus 7
Next generation Google Nexus 7 could launch in July for $229
New Google Nexus 7 for $229 in July of 2013? This could be another hit Android product for Google.
Samsung Galaxy S4 Active
Samsung Galaxy S4 Active to be AT&T exclusive at $199.99
Samsung Galaxy S4 Active is going to be launched on June 21 and if you are interested in this water-
Samsung Galaxy S4
T-Mobile drops Galaxy S4 price by $50 for one month
There is some good news for people who are on T-Mobile network and want to buy the new Samsung
iPad mini
Apple's next iPad mini 7.9 inch Retina display will be Samsung-made
Apple's new iPad mini will sport 7.9 inch Retina display with 2048 x 1539 pixel resolution. The
Low cost iPhone
Low cost iPhone reportedly shipping in large numbers
Is Apple scrambling to launch a low-cost iPhone in 2013?
Microsoft Office 365 Home Premium
Microsoft Office now available for iPhones, but there's a catch
Microsoft finally released its Office Mobile for iPhone as a free app, but there's a catch: it's
Nokia EOS Leaked
Nokia EOS 41-megapixel camera smartphone may debut on July 11
Nokia has a big event scheduled for July 11 in New York and the 'Zoom. Reinvented' teaser on the
HTC Tiara
Sprint HTC Tiara Windows Phone 8 smartphone leaks in PR image
The Sprint-bound HTC Tiara made its way to the Internet in an official PR image, complete with
Galaxy S2 Jelly Bean Update
Android 4.1.2 Jelly Bean finally available for AT&T Samsung Galaxy S2 (SGH-I777)
Android 4.1.2 Jelly Bean update finally comes via Samsung Kies to put Samsung Galaxy S2 users on
Copyright © 2013 Mobile & Apps All rights reserved. mobilenapps
Real Time Analytics