Judge David Shaw from the International Trade Commission has decided that Microsoft Xbox 360 video game console does not infringe on Motorola Mobility patents, which is a complete reversal of his previous ruling in 2012.
It's not over yet though - the ITC will review Shaw's findings and make a final decision come July 23 to end this matter once and for all. However, it might get dragged out a few more lengths as Google and Motorola are definitely interested in appealing the ruling in hopes to prove that Microsoft did in fact infringe on key patented technology.
Back in 2010, Motorola Mobility, now owned by Google, sued Microsoft over video coding and wireless patents which, according to Motorola, was used in the Xbox and Windows Phone devices.
In May of 2010, Judge Shaw ruled in favor of Motorola, claiming the Xbox 360 Slim video game console did infringe on the patents and should be banned from import in the United States. However, the commission returned the case back to Shaw, asking him to reconsider the ruling due to a new model set by another case. This lead to Shaw changing his tune in favor of Microsoft, which does not bode very well for both Google and Motorola.
According to Google spokesperson, Matt Kallman, "We are disappointed with today's determination and look forward to the full commission's review."
However, Microsoft vice president, David Howard, was no doubt pleased with the outcome. "We are pleased with the administrative law judge's finding that Microsoft did not violate Motorola's patent and are confident that this determination will be affirmed by the commission."
The battle between Microsoft and Google does not end here. Both companies are vying for the control of the mobile space, and as things continue to heat up, expect more confrontations similar this one.
most read
related stories
more stories from Gadgets
Explore the top 6 water-resistant phones of 2024, designed to withstand any adventure. Stay connected, rain or shine!
ernest hamiltonDiscover the top smartphones of 2024 tailored for music and movie enthusiasts. Elevate your entertainment experience today!
ernest hamiltonDiscover the top 5 Android phones tailored for students in 2024! Don't miss out on this comprehensive guide to find the perfect device for your academic journey.
ernest hamiltonDeciding between Samsung Galaxy S20 FE 5G and iPhone 13? Find the best phone for teens with this detailed comparison.
ernest hamiltonDiscover 8 Parent-Approved Phones for Kids and Teens! Make the right choice for your child's first smartphone. Read our guide now!
ernest hamiltonGalaxy S24 Plus vs. iPhone 15 Plus: Clash of flagship titans! Explore the battle between Samsung's latest Galaxy and Apple's upcoming iPhone. Discover which reigns supreme!
ernest hamiltonMidrange Android showdown: Nothing Phone 2a vs Asus Zenfone 10. Discover which device reigns supreme in our in-depth comparison. Read now for the ultimate smartphone decision!
ernest hamiltonHumane AI Pin Review: Falls short of being a true 'smartphone killer'. Dive into our comprehensive review to uncover the strengths and limitations of this intriguing device.
ernest hamilton